Or that it remain, but only upon the caveat that it must immediately be followed by a an explanation that silkworths opinion was entirely reflective of the limited scientific knowledge and progress of his era that being the 1930s, and b that this definitive statement written by the titular inventor of the sinclair method. The roundtable of aa history january 10, 1998 william duncan silkworth, md 18731951 from mike o. Alcoholics anonymous, the doctor s opinion the first and second edition book alcoholics anon. The doctors opinion on alcoholism was presented on november 15, 2011. Alcoholics anonymous archivist, author conducts sessions here.
Doctor silkworth describes him as a case of pathological mental deterioration. The second edition added the appendices, the twelve traditions, and the directions for getting in touch with a. Silkworth on jesus christ twelve step people who study a. The big book of alcoholics anonymous kindle edition by. There is also some brief writing by bill wilson, the founder of alcoholics anonymous. We of alcoholics anonymous believe that the reader will be interested in the medical estimate of the plan of recovery described in this book. The big book of alcoholics anonymous kindle edition by silkworth m. Original aa members documented their experience in the big book.
These members realized a 72% success rate from 19341938 died sober using this spiritual program of action. Alcoholics anonymous the doctor s opinion the little doctor who loved drunksa letter from dr. Men and women drink essentially because they like the effect produced by alcohol. Site map silkworth history biographies big book search contact go back email this print this the doctor s opinion we of alcoholics anonymous believe that the reader will be interested in the medical estimate of the plan of recovery described in this book. As a laymen, our opinion as to its soundness may, of course, mean little. The doctors opinion was page one and the basic text ended at page 179. This site is like a library, you could find million book here by using search box in the header. William silkworth, the medical director of townes hospital and one of the leading physicians.
Read this and get immediate medical attention for anyone suspected of having alcohol withdrawal symptoms. How carl jung inspired the creation of alcoholics anonymous. Convincing testimony must surely come from medical men who have had experience with the sufferings of our members and have witnessed our return to health. Towns hospital for drug and alcohol addictions in new york city in the 1930s, during which time bill wilson, a future cofounder of alcoholics anonymous a. The doctors opinion occupied its own section in the first edition of alcoholics anonymous, and remained unchanged in the 2 nd, 3 rd, and 4 th editions. Appear before police today in caste slur case, bombay hc. The exproblem drinker xiv, 18, 20 there is a solution. In april 1939, some 5,000 copies of the big book titled alcoholics anonymous roll off the press. Fired again first edition big book story silkworth. Alcoholics anonymous, big book the doctors opinion audio.
Following are excerpts from the comments of doctors present at the annual meeting of the medical society of the state of new york where a paper on a. Silkworths name was not added to the the doctors opinion until publication of the 2 nd edition in 1955. Jan 29, 2016 the doctors opinion the doctors opinion contains two letters written by william d. This edition features pagemarkers which correlate directly to the actual physical pagenumbers in all editions of the big book so you can now followalong or read at meetings on you nook in addition to the readalong core text, this edition also contains dr. Silkworth s opinion relates to the modern neurobiolgy of addictive illness, and identification of therapy for alcoholism as promoted by alcoholics anonymous and its relationship to dr. Doctor s opinion was page 1 in the first edition of the big book xxvxxxii. Silkworth expressed a sense of real satisfaction when i was asked to contribute a few words on a subject which is covered in such masterly detail in these pages.
Like much of the alcoholics anonymous history, exact dates are unclear. Officially begun on december 12th, 2000, silkworth. The history of alcoholics anonymous beginners classes. The big book of alcoholics anonymous and twelve step programs across the world have helped millions of people recover from addictions, in large part because of doctor silkworth. The letter by dr silkworth that opens the big book of alcoholics anonymous was written july 27, 1938 under the letterhead of the charles b. Alcoholics anonymous, big book the doctors opinion.
He is mentioned in the doctor s opinion page xxix of the big book. These facts appear to be of extreme medical importance. Reprinted with permission from the grapevine magazine. The 2 nd edition big book was introduced 16 years later at the historic 1955 international convention in st louis. Silkworth s explanation of alcoholism as a twofold disease, affecting mind and body, how dr. But, silkworth added, he adopted the plan outlined in this book. Reading guide for the doctors opinion amethyst recovery center. This is the second video for the chapter the doctor s opinion of the alcoholics anonymous. The book they wrote, alcoholics anonymous the big book, is the basic text for aa on how to stay sober. Francis and the aa book 12 steps and 12 traditions. The doctor s theory that we have an allergy to alcohol interests us. Silkworth, a prominent physician in the addictions field, wrote. May 18, 2020 read online the big book alcoholics anonymous silkworth. Alcoholics anonymous big book by william silkworth.
The doctors opinion second edition big book podcast. Chhagan bhujbal is stable with medications, says medical. William duncan silkworth henceforth be removed from all printings of the big book. We, of alcoholics anonymous, are more than one hundred men and women who have recovered from a seemingly hopeless state of mind and body. Alcoholic addiction xxv or xxvii 1st edition the doctor s opinion dr. Alcoholics anonymous aa big book 12 step program who.
Provided to youtube by cdbabythe doctor s opinion alcoholics anonymousalcoholics anonymous. I have specialized in the treatment of alcoholism for many years. The section called the doctor s opinion has been kept intact, just as it was originally written in 1939 by the late dr. The book titled, alcoholics anonymous preface silkworth. Aug 05, 20 some people get over allergies, but we learn later in the big book, that alcoholics never get over alcoholism. The doctors opinion w e ofalcoholics anonymous believe that the reader will be interested in the medical esti mate of the plan of recovery described in this book. They can produce a sense of ease and comfort and contentment. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the big book of alcoholics anonymous. We demand that the chapter the doctors opinion of the. A wellknown doctor, chief physician at a nationally prominent hospital specializing in alcoholic and drug addiction, gave alcoholics anonymous this letter. The story of how many thousands of men and women have recovered from alcoholism is a 1939 basic text, describing how to recover from alcoholism. This disappointment foreshadows a bleak summer for the new york fellowship. Chapter three breaks down the early history of doctor silkworth, doctor bob and bill wilson.
Nov 04, 2015 tamara cites the first chapter of aas big book, called the doctors opinion, written by dr. Following the forewords, there appears a section called the doctor s opinion. Tradition spiritual experience the medical view on a. Oct 14, 20 appear before police today in caste slur case, bombay hc tells doctor more classrooms, faculty needed for law college operation done without patients consent is an assault. Even after his own conversion experience, which silkworth, like jung, recommended he pursue, wilson experimented with vitamin therapies, through the. Silkworth s first endorsement of alcoholics anonymous, medical societies and physicians throughout the world have set their approval upon us.
The chapter the doctors opinion we discuss letters from dr william d. Big book name and date references aa in the desert. Bill renumbered the pages of the 2 nd edition so that page one began with bills story instead of the doctors opinion. It was primarily written by one of the founders of alcoholics anonymous aa, bill wilson with two chapters, to employers written by henry parkhurst. The letter by dr silkworth that opens the big book of alcoholics anonymous was written july 27, 1938 under the letterhead of the charles b towns hospital a medical facility with a national reputation in alcohol and drug addiction treatment. After the foreword is a section called the doctors opinion, which details the observations and beliefs of dr. William duncan silkworth, 18731951 was an american medical doctor and specialist in the treatment of alcoholism. Men and women drink essentially because they like the effect produced by. Chapter two is the doctor s opinion out of the big book. He has lost everything worthwhile in life and was only living, one might say, to drink. Recovery from addiction why an entire psychic change is. The doctors opinion on alcoholism revisited november 2011. Alcoholics anonymous aa big book 12 step program who was.
Aa speakers joe and charlie the doctors opinion the big book comes alive. Chapter two is the doctor s opinion from the big book of alcoholics anonymous. Is alcoholics anonymous really a harmful religious cult. Hank is first mentioned in the doctor s opinion on page xxix of the big book. The doctors opinion study questions alcoholics anonymous. Alcoholics anonymous, the book, alcoholics anonymous, the big book, the book, the twelve steps and twelve traditions. Preface forward to first edition forward to second edition the doctor s opinion bills story there is a solution more about alcoholism we agnostics how it works into action working with others to wives the family afterward to employers a vision for you the a. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it. After an anticipated readers digest article fails to materialize and a radio broadcast results in no orders, sales are few and far between.
Silkworth contributing the section on the doctors opinion. The doctors opinion we of alcoholics anonymous believe that the reader will be interested in the medical estimate of the plan of recovery described in. Silkworth contends that the discoveries outlinelined in this d in this book are of extraordinary medical importance and may. Silkworth begins his opinion in a letter to alcoholics anonymous in which he describes the treatment and recovery of one of a. But as exproblem drinkers, we can say that his explanation makes good sense. Chapter four is a history of the oxford group and the twelve steps. That sentence, the lord has been so wonderful to me, curing me of this terrible disease, that i just want to keep telling people about it, has been a sort of a golden text for the a. William silkworth wrote the letters in the chapter titled the doctors opinion in the book alcoholics anonymous. It is from the title of this book that the group got its name. Here you will experience much historical and related information on the subject of alcoholics anonymous and alcoholics anonymous history. We the people demand one of the three following things of alcoholics anonymous world services, inc 1. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Annotated big book 1955 looking for a meeting near you. The doctors opinion the doctors opinion contains two letters written by william d.
Alcoholics anonymous is a fellowship of men and wome. The doctor s opinion on alcoholism was presented on november 15, 2011. Convincing testimony must surely come from medical men who have had experience with the sufferings of. This is an audio reading from the big book of alcoholics anonymous. The unbeliever was published in the 1 st edition of the big book alcoholics anonymous. A recent biography 2002 describes his life and work. Silkworth, who theorized that alcoholism was in part a physical disease, a sort of metabolism difficulty which he then called an allergy. Reading guide for the doctors opinion amethyst recovery. But on one level, the idea of an allergy is a good one. Silkworth was an alcoholism researcher and treatment provider at the towns hospital in new york city. We demand that the chapter the doctors opinion of the big.
She said, a private doctor s opinion cannot be sought or relied on over the medical. The big book of alcoholics anonymous opens with the doctors opinion, which was written by dr. Silkworth who contributed greatly to our young fellowship in its adolescence. Preface forward to first edition forward to second edition the doctor s opinion bills story there is a solution more about alcoholism we agnostics how it works into action working with others to wives the family afterward to employers a vision for you the. May 27, 2016 he cannot sit over a report by a nine doctor panel of jj which says no surgical intervention is required. If we practice the 12 steps, we are granted a daily reprieve. An explanation of addictive illness found in the big book of. Emotions produce euphoric and intoxicating effects. Nov 18, 2014 doctors opinion 11 the main point of alcoholics anonymous is to show precisely how, i. Silkworth chronic alcoholics pg xxv, xxvi, xxviii, xxix, 27 the doctor s opinion. Instead, bill and bob formed a nonprofit group called the alcoholic foundation and published a book that shared their personal experiences and what they did to stay sober. What is the name of the companion group to alcoholics anonymous for the families of alcoholics. Jun 22, 2015 the letter by dr silkworth that opens the big book of alcoholics anonymous was written july 27, 1938 under the letterhead of the charles b towns hospital a medical facility with a national reputation in alcohol and drug addiction treatment. Psychological rehabilitation of alcoholics psychological rehabilitation of alcoholics by william d.
The doctors opinion we of alcoholics anonymous believe that the reader will be interested in the medical estimate of the plan of recovery described in this book. This also has been kept intact, just as it was originally written in 1939 by the late dr. Doctor silkworth was the first in his field to look at alcoholism and drug addiction in a disease model that he called an allergy of the body, and an obsession of the mind. The medical record, july 19, 1939 this is an expanded letter from silky, parts of which. Alcoholics anonymous, chapter 5, how it works, aa, dr bob, bill w, big book, 12 steps, recovered, powerless, 1st step.
98 491 683 1216 535 855 711 1847 136 672 723 974 60 85 286 1283 450 1337 1558 1127 260 91 462 1724 484 1570 943